Checked on November 17, 2026 against the sources listed below.
The short answer
- Pattern: light, bean-shaped spots on a dark body on a pike; dark bars or spots on a light body on a muskie.
- Jaw pores: five or fewer per side on a pike, six or more on a muskie, a row of four on a pickerel.
- Cheek: fully scaled on a pike; scaled only on the top half on a muskie.
- Tail: pointed lobes on a true muskie; rounded lobes on a pike and a tiger muskie.
- A chainlike pattern and a dark bar below the eye point to a chain pickerel.
Side by side
| Northern pike | Muskellunge | Pickerels (chain, grass, redfin) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pattern | Light spots on a dark green body | Dark bars or spots on a light body | Chainlike dark lines (chain) or often dark bars (grass, redfin) |
| Pores under the jaw | Five or fewer per side | Six or more per side | A row of four |
| Cheek scales | Whole cheek | Top half only | Whole cheek |
| Gill cover scales | Top half only | Top half only | Whole gill cover |
| Tail lobes | Rounded | Pointed | Not described in these sources |
| Size, as Missouri gives it | To more than 4 feet | Commonly 36 to 45 inches in Missouri | Chain 16 to 22 inches; grass seldom over 12 |
Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
Start with the pattern
The quickest look is the color pattern. A northern pike is bluish green to gray with rows of light, bean-shaped spots along its sides: light marks on a dark body. A muskie is the reverse, with dark vertical bars or dark spots: the Iowa DNR describes its base color as olive to dark gray, and Missouri calls its background light. The Iowa DNR notes that a muskie's bars vary a lot from fish to fish.
Young fish can look different. Iowa says young pike have slanted light and dark bars rising from a white belly, and young muskies can show dark spots all over a silvery body. That is why the next two checks matter.
Count the pores under the jaw
Pike and muskies both have a row of small pores on the underside of the lower jaw, which sense vibrations in the water. Muskies always have more. The Iowa DNR's rule: five or fewer pores on each side is a pike; six or more on either side is a muskie. The Missouri Department of Conservation gives a pike 5 pores per side and a muskie 6 to 9.
The pickerels have fewer still: Missouri gives both the chain and the grass pickerel a row of four.
Check the cheek scales and the tail
Cheek. A pike's cheek is scaled all over. A muskie's cheek has scales only on the top half, and the bottom half of its gill cover is bare too. The pike's gill cover is also scaled only on its top half, so look at the cheek. Pickerels have both the cheek and the gill cover fully scaled.
Tail. Iowa says a true muskie's tail lobes come to points, while pike and tiger muskie tails have rounded lobes. West Virginia adds that a pike's pectoral and pelvic fins are more rounded as well. Iowa notes that these fish are predators and sometimes cannibals, so a tail damaged in a fight can mislead.
The tiger muskie
A tiger muskie is a hybrid of a northern pike and a muskellunge. It is sterile and cannot reproduce. West Virginia's DNR says the state has them only from hatchery crosses, though natural crosses happen in northern lake states where both parents are common. They are usually stocked to give anglers a fishery, and they often grow faster than either parent.
Its markings mix the two parents: dark vertical bars and irregular dark spots over an olive to dark gray body, and West Virginia describes bars and spots that alternate or blend together. Like a pike, it has rounded fins and rounded tail lobes. Because it does not breed, knowing whether tiger muskies have been stocked in that water helps.
The pickerels
The Missouri Department of Conservation describes the northern pike as like a larger version of the pickerels. All of them share the pike family's snout shaped like a duck's bill, a large mouth full of sharp teeth, and one back fin set far back near the tail.
Chain pickerel have an olive or yellowish brown body with a chainlike pattern of dark lines along the sides, and a vertical black bar below the eye. A northern pike has neither. Missouri gives their length as 16 to 22 inches.
Grass and redfin pickerel are two forms of one species. They are smaller, with a shorter snout than the chain pickerel, and often dark vertical bars or mottling instead of a chain pattern. Missouri's grass pickerel also has a dusky bar slanting down and back from the eye. The redfin has red fins and lives in Atlantic coast rivers as far south as Georgia. Missouri says the grass pickerel seldom grows past 10 to 12 inches.
Size, water, and before you keep one
The muskie is the largest of the pikes. Missouri gives the northern pike as reaching more than 4 feet and 40 pounds, and the muskie in Missouri as commonly 36 to 45 inches. West Virginia's DNR lists its largest angler-caught northern pike at 42.6 inches and 22.06 pounds, and its largest tiger musky at 49.25 inches and 36.5 pounds.
Pike prefer slow water with dense plants: lakes, deeper wetlands and bays of larger rivers. Muskies prefer clear water with aquatic plants. The Iowa DNR says both are found in big lakes and rivers that hold plenty of prey fish.
The Iowa DNR notes that the rules for pike and muskie are different. Rules depend on the state and the water and change over time, and fish that look alike can fall under different rules, so check your state fish and wildlife agency before you keep one.


