Checked on November 17, 2026 against the sources listed below.
The short answer
- Red or orange slash under the jaw, spots crowded toward the tail: cutthroat trout.
- Pink or red stripe and black spots spread from head to tail: rainbow trout. A steelhead is a rainbow trout that went to sea.
- Large black spots plus red spots with pale halos, few or no spots on the tail: brown trout.
- Light spots on a dark body: brook trout if the back has wormlike marks and the dorsal fin is spotted; bull trout if the dorsal fin is plain.
- Light spots and a deeply forked tail: lake trout.
Side by side
| Spots | Other marks | Tail | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rainbow trout | Black, spread from head to tail | Pink or red stripe; white tips on the pelvic and anal fins | Clearly forked, with dark spots |
| Cutthroat trout | Dark, sparse near the head, crowded toward the tail | Red or orange slash under the lower jaw | Not described in these sources |
| Brown trout | Large black spots, plus red spots with pale halos | Usually an orange edge on the small adipose fin | Square or slightly forked, few or no spots |
| Brook trout (char) | Pale and red spots, some with blue halos | Wormlike marks on the back and dorsal fin; white front edge on lower fins | Square or slightly forked |
| Bull trout (char) | Yellow spots above, red or orange on the sides, no blue halos | Plain dorsal fin; white front edge on lower fins | Slightly forked |
| Lake trout (char) | Light gray spots on a dark gray body | No pink or blue spots | Deeply forked |
Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
Trout and char: start with the spots
Idaho Fish and Game groups trout with salmon and whitefish as salmonids. The fish in this guide fall into two groups. Rainbow, cutthroat and brown trout have dark spots. Brook trout, bull trout and lake trout are char, and they have light spots on a darker body.
Idaho Fish and Game gives a simple rule: body color varies from fish to fish, but the pattern of spots is usually the same within a species, so look at the spots before the color.
Rainbow trout and cutthroat trout
Rainbow trout have black spots on the body, tail and back fins, a bluish-green to dark olive back, and silver sides and belly. A pink or red stripe often runs along the side. Fish in lakes can look silvery. White tips on the belly (pelvic) and anal fins are usually easy to see, and the tail is clearly forked.
Cutthroat trout are named for the red or orange slash under the lower jaw. Their spots are sparse near the head and crowded toward the tail; on a rainbow they are spread more evenly from head to tail. Body color varies. Idaho Fish and Game says cutthroat were recently split into four species, Coastal, Westslope, Lahontan and Rocky Mountain cutthroat, which share these marks.
Rainbow and cutthroat can breed in the wild. Idaho says these hybrids, called cutbows, are common there: a trout with a jaw slash, evenly spread spots and some white-tipped fins is likely one.
Brown trout
Brown trout have a brown or olive back with large black spots, and red or orange spots on the sides inside pale or blue-gray halos. The small fleshy fin that sits behind the dorsal fin (the adipose fin) usually has an orange edge. The tail has few or no spots. Missouri says the tail is usually not forked; Idaho calls it slightly forked.
Brown trout are not native. The Missouri Department of Conservation says they come from Europe and the British Isles and were brought to the United States as early as 1883.
Brook trout vs bull trout
These two char can be hard to tell apart, especially when small. Both have light spots on a dark background, a white front edge on the lower fins, and an orange or red belly at spawning time. Idaho Fish and Game gives three checks:
- Dorsal fin. A brook trout's is spotted or mottled. A bull trout's is plain.
- Back. A brook trout has squiggly, wormlike marks. A bull trout does not.
- Halos. Some brook trout have blue halos around a few side spots. A bull trout has none.
The brook trout's native range is eastern North America, from the Great Lakes to the Atlantic and south along the Appalachians to Georgia. The bull trout's native range is the Pacific Northwest, Alaska and Canada; it needs cold water and is most common in high mountain areas.
Idaho notes that bull trout are listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act, and that this is why telling them from brook trout matters. Rules for the two can differ, so check your state fish and wildlife agency.
Lake trout
Lake trout, also called mackinaw, are char. They are dark gray or gray-green with irregular light gray spots on the back, sides, dorsal fin and tail, and no pink or blue spots. Idaho Fish and Game notes that the deeply forked tail separates a lake trout from a bull trout, whose tail is not deeply forked. In Idaho they live only in large, deep lakes.
Rainbow trout vs steelhead
They are the same species, Oncorhynchus mykiss. NOAA Fisheries explains that fish spending their whole lives in fresh water are called rainbow trout, while steelhead migrate to the ocean, usually grow larger, and come back to fresh water to spawn. Unlike most Pacific salmon, a steelhead can spawn more than once.
A steelhead looks very much like a rainbow trout but is usually much bigger. Idaho describes adults as generally 20 to 40 inches, with evenly spaced dark spots onto the tail, a dark green to pale silvery green body, and a pink or red stripe and cheek patch whose colors usually deepen at spawning time. Washington describes dark spots over the whole fish, including the tail, with slight to strong rainbow coloring.
NOAA lists steelhead in Alaska and along the West Coast, where several populations are protected under the Endangered Species Act. Rules for steelhead and rainbow trout can differ, so check your state fish and wildlife agency before you keep one.


